Chimneys Archives - Page 3 of 5 - Charles Buell Consulting LLC

November 10, 2012 by Charles Buell

Jurassic Chimney!

When we bought our house and started to make improvements on it—-back before I was a Seattle Home Inspector—-I was heavily influenced by a couple of fun movies playing at the time: Jumanjiand Jurassic Park.

The house had wall-to-wall shag, puce-green carpeting—-if one could really call it carpeting. There was most likely a microscopic Jurassic Park of critters living in the thing. In appearance the carpet was more reminiscent of one of those cat clawing poles that people have in their homes.

In front of the dining room window, there was a 2’ x 6’ runner on top of the carpeting. This runner covered over a humongous hole the sun had burned through the carpet. This runner had been nailed all around its perimeter with roofing nails—-an inch apart—-kind of like the nailing pattern you might see on the underside of an upholstered chair or like the rivets in a jet wing. The nail heads were all shiny from wear—-quite attractive and “sparkly.”

Like almost all homes of this vintage, in this area, most of the rooms had face-nailed wood strip flooring under this carpeting. With some elbow grease this flooring did re-finish quite nicely. The hallway however was another matter. It had been patched numerous times and covered over with linoleum. The adhesive was not about to be completely removed either. So I decided to do a “painted rug” to deal with the matter. Here is a picture of what it looks like.

Fern leaf Faux floor — Faux Fern Leaf Floor

I think you can see the Jurassic Park influence. I took actual ferns from the garden and rolled them in paint and then pressed them onto the floor—-bunches of different colors—-bunches of different layers.

I had another Jurassic moment on an inspection the other day—or perhaps it would be more correct to say the chimney was having a Jurassic moment. Hopefully a bunch of manic monkeys, two hundred pound mosquitoes and raging rhinos are not going to come flooding out of it—-like in Jumanji.

By Charles Buell, Real Estate Inspections in Seattle

If you enjoyed this post, and would like to get notices of new posts to my blog, please subscribe via email in the little box to the right. I promise NO spamming of your email

October 29, 2012 by Charles Buell

Don’t you just hate masonry chimneys?

Perhaps the most important component of a chimney is the Crown (mortar cap) around the flue at the top of the chimney—-and a proper hat on the flue itself.

This post is not about the kinds of damage that can be done to chimneys from the inside by the appliances that are connected to them. Wood, gas and oil appliances ruin chimneys every day. Today’s post is about the kind of damage that happens to chimneys from external forces—-namely WATER! Water can be just as hard on masonry as it can be on wood, and like wood the structure must be properly constructed to protect it the best that it can be from water damage.

The Mortar Cap, or Crown, rarely gets done properly. The mortar cap should hang past the edges of the chimney so that water sheds off the top of the chimney—kind of like the overhang on the roof of the house keeps the roof water from running down the siding—-if there are no gutters. This necessary overhang is not present 99% of the time on chimneys and 99% of those that have overhangs have no drip groove on the underside that prevents water from wrapping around the overhang. Most chimneys suffer from lack of an overhanging cap. A proper overhanging cap can greatly protect sides away from the wind from being impacted by water running off the cap on at least those sides. Without it, water that hits the cap runs down all sides of the chimney.

The basic purpose of the crown (and the flue hat) is to keep water out of the chimney structure. This is especially important in regions where temperatures drop below freezing. Water that freezes inside of chimneys expands and destroys bricks and mortar—-which allows for even more water infiltration.

It should be obvious from this first picture that water WILL enter the chimney structure.

The mortar joints can deteriorate to the extent that holes will become visible all the way through the chimney—-as was the case with this chimney.

Metal liner visible because of missing mortar

Can you see the metal flue liner between the bricks?

Most chimneys have a crown of mortar that is merely a think layer of concrete troweled around the flues and terminated flush with the face of the brick. This creates a very thin area at the brick edges that cracks and loosens easily. It is much better to pour a more monolithic concrete slab that has enough thickness that it is not subject to the expansion and contraction cracking typical of very thin mortar crowns. Ideally this crown will overhang the face of the brick on all sides and have a drip groove on the underside of the overhang to prevent water from wrapping around onto the brick face. In any event the crown must be kept sealed so that moisture cannot get into any cracks that do form in the cap as well as at the connection of the cap and the flue. A large hat on the flue can also aid in protecting this vulnerable area. This next picture shows a poorly made and badly deteriorated mortar crown that no longer protects the chimney structure at all.

Loose chimney liner—mortar cap in very poor condition

This particular chimney (and there are many like them) is constructed of bricks that are hollow. These types of chimneys are particularly vulnerable to damage from water once the water finds its way into the structure.

One particular method of attempting to create a more functional crown is for the mason to overhang the top rows of bricks. While this is “somewhat” better than NO overhang, it still has no drip groove on the underside and the mortar cap is still too thin at the edge of the bricks. If you look closely at this next picture you will see the failing of the thin edge of the mortar cap, the gaps around the flues, and the obvious crack through the mortar cap extending down the center face of the chimney. All of these conditions allow for large amounts of water to enter the chimney structure.

Now if you would like to see how they are “supposed” to be done, check out this schematic from the Masonry Advisory Council.

Someday I hope to have an “actual” picture of a proper cap taken in the field—we will probably stop building masonry chimneys before that happens.

Charles Buell, Real Estate Inspections in Seattle

If you enjoyed this post, and would like to get notices of new posts to my blog, please subscribe via email in the little box to the right. I promise NO spamming of your email

September 5, 2012 by Charles Buell

Real life Jenga

I used to love playing Jenga with my kids—it is a great game that requires skill, patience, planning and an “appreciation” of gravity. One wrong move and the whole thing could collapse.

Over the years I have seen a lot of chimneys. In fact a chimney almost got me fired back in 1970 when I was working part time for one of my college professors. This was all way before I could have ever imagined ending up being a Seattle Home Inspector some 39 years later.

I spent weekends and breaks doing handyman work for him while his house was being remodeled. I ended up working for my professor’s builder for about a year after he fired the guy he had working for him at the time.

While the following incident is not what got the helper fired, I am sure it did not help his case any. The builder sent him up on the roof to start shingling the roof. The roof had been covered with felt paper the day before. We could here the dull thud of “occasional” nails being driven—-until the builder couldn’t stand it any longer and he went up on the roof to see what kind of “progress” the helper was making.

The helper was shingling the roof from the top down!

When questioned about this “less than conventional” approach to installing shingles, the helper merely stated, “This the way I always do it.”

After this event—-and some other events that ultimately got the helper fired, I figured this was my chance to ask the builder for a job. I figured I could EASILY do better than this helper.

The next day—-or soon thereafter—-the builder sent me up on an older part of the roof to tear down the chimney. Seemed simple enough, and even sounded like fun. So, there I was up on the roof and knocking the bricks apart and throwing them two stories down onto the lawn—-having a ton of fun trying to hit the bricks that were already embedded in the grass below. It was not long before I had a growing pile of bricks and a boss running and screaming out of the house like he had pulled up his trousers with a hornet’s nest in them. He was waving his hat—-his bald red head glistening in the sun—-saying things I really can’t repeat here. He wanted to know what the “H” “E” double hockey sticks I thought I was doing. After he calmed down a bit, he informed me that he meant the OTHER chimney. “Oh,” I said.

He didn’t fire me—and the rest of the story—-is my whole life.

Like I said at the start of this post—-over the years, I have seen a lot of chimneys.

The chimney pictured above is perhaps the worst chimney I have ever seen. And I am sure that left to its own devices it will soon find its way to the lawn below, “That is the way they always do it.”

Jenga anyone?

By Charles Buell, Real Estate Inspections in Seattle

If you enjoyed this post, and would like to get notices of new posts to my blog, please subscribe via email in the little box to the right. I promise NO spamming of your email